06/05/2008
from the Kennebec Journal
QUESTIONS REMAIN
No complaints from those who switched to Somerset County center
Vote on 1 may hurt some in election
Steeple at center of debate in Whitefield
VETERANS REQUIRE ASSISTANCE: Homelessness takes center stage
J.P. DEVINE: Overcome sadness with hope
BASKETBALL: NBA Hall of Famer Barry doles out advice at Thomas College
HIGH SCHOOL CROSS COUNTRY: Maranacook sophomore Mace dominates Class B field
All of today's:
News | Sports
from the Kennebec Journal
from the Morning Sentinel
A year later, families await answers on fatalities
Owner of topless coffee shop on the comeback trail
Officials report cheaper, better service after switch
Two people in critical condition
Young Marines stick to program
Issue of homeless veterans at center stage
GIRLS SOCCER STATE CHAMPIONSHIP: Winslow falls to York in Class B
Bard hits her marathon stride
All of today's:
News | Sports
from the Morning Sentinel
When a student organized an art project using flag replicas at the University of Maine at Farmington earlier this spring, I listened to voices from all over the world -- there were easily more than 1,000 e-mails, letters and phone calls.
The communications came from students, faculty, and staff at UMF; alumni; veterans; members of the armed forces who are currently serving; parents; concerned citizens and others. I tried to respond to every one.
In late April, we had a campus dialogue about the issues raised by the project, in which the student placed replicas of American flags on the floor of a college building. Some of the questions we explored were:
* What is the role of patriotism in debate about big national issues?
* What does our flag really symbolize?
* Should permissible art exhibits have any limits on campus?
* What do members of the campus community have a right to expect about provocative things they may be confronted with?
* Is politeness the highest value?
* What does "safety" mean -- is it only physical or is it more?
* What does the First Amendment really mean, and are there any limits on free speech at all?
The art project gave us the gift of making these questions alive and urgent, and our students, faculty and staff who engaged in this exchange did so in a respectful and courteous fashion.
Politeness and courtesy really do have a place. They are extremely useful in the social process of argument, which presupposes a common willingness to engage in dialogue in the search for truth.
We didn't agree with one another, and opinions ranged across the whole political spectrum from right to left, but we all learned that every speaker had something important to contribute to the debate. I was proud of everyone who took part.
We plan to have another discussion to celebrate Constitution Day in September, and we'll invite our wider community to participate. There need to be more occasions for constructive dialogue within and across our communities, since the most common model we have these days seems to be talk shows, including political "debates," where people scream at each other instead of conversing.
Screaming is not conducive to listening. Insults and personal attacks make us close our ears and our hearts. We stop listening in self-defense. We cannot accept the gifts that others long to give us.
I found as I listened to people that there is a hunger for true dialogue: Many people were surprised that they received a polite response from me and were eager to keep the exchange going.
I daresay more searching conversations took place at UMF, in classes, in group discussions and in various homes across the state and beyond as a result of this art project.
Isn't this what education is about?
In case you are not able to engage in difficult conversations in person, there is something that you can do, using these very editorial pages with their wide range of political opinions. Just read every single editorial and op-ed column for one week, and try to do it with an open and receptive mind.
Hold your usual labels and presuppositions in suspension, open yourself to the gift of listening, and see if you don't learn something new. Listening is hard, and nobody said this would be easy work, but it is the work I believe we as citizens and members of our communities are called upon to do.
Theodora J. Kalikow is president of the University of Maine at Farmington. She can be reached at kalikow@maine.edu




Reader comments
Click here to view or add reader comments