Morning Sentinel
IN MAINE SCHOOLS
Sugar
intake
not yet
licked
By SUSAN M. COVER
Staff Writer
Kennebec Journal & Morning Sentinel 11/28/2007

AUGUSTA -- Efforts by the state to rid schools of soda and candy have been successful, but there's evidence that students are finding other ways to get that sugary high.

They've switched to sports drinks and flavored water, some of which can be deceptively high in calories, said Janet Whatley Blum, a University of Southern Maine professor in the Department of Exercise, Health and Sport Sciences.

"It's great they got soda out of schools, but there's still sugar-sweetened beverages in schools," she said Tuesday following a speech at the Augusta Civic Center.

Blum kicked off Tuesday's daylong conference on obesity sponsored by the Maine-Harvard Prevention Research Center. She presented findings from a study conducted at 11 Maine high schools that looked to see what impact a 2005 state rule had on soda and candy in schools.

The rule extends the regulation of "foods of minimal nutritional value" from only the school day to 24 hours a day, seven days a week. It applies to schools that participate in the federal meal programs.

And though the rule seeks to regulate candy and soda on school property, local school boards could, and did, carve out exceptions, Blum said.

Some opted to allow soda and candy machines in the teachers' lounge and to allow the sale of those items at events open to the public. Also, school boards can vote to exempt culinary arts programs.

By surveying school food service directors and visiting the schools, Blum found that, although schools pulled soda from their vending machines, other sugar-filled options remain.

In the 11 schools observed, sugar-sweetened beverages accounted for 32 percent of all beverages in vending programs, she said. And candy is still being sold in school stores even though it's not supposed to be, according to the state Department of Education.

For those who work in schools, the transition to healthier offerings wasn't easy.

"The kids whined," said Lori Muzzy, a food service director for the Rangeley Lakes Regional School. "Their parents whined."

Eventually, the whining stopped and Muzzy said she successfully works with vendors to substitute better choices.

In Augusta, Director of School Nutrition Programs Barbara Raymond-Nichols said she wants to be more aggressive in trying to change the way students eat.

"I'm not in favor of banning birthday cakes, but it's time we start getting kids more active and teach them how to select foods," she said.

Adults also need to lead by example, she said.

Which brings us to the teachers lounge, where Blum and her crew snapped pictures of soda machines and vending machines stuffed full of chips, candy bars and other goodies.

They also found baskets of candy on the desks of teachers, guidance counselors and principals.

And then there's the all-you-can-eat pizza, french fry and soda buffet across the street from one of the state's high schools -- Blum didn't say which.

She said it might be time to consider additional steps to fight obesity. And she said the message needs to extend beyond the schoolhouse door and into the home.

"In general, I see schools doing a very good job or moving in that direction, to have kids be in a healthy food environment," she said.

Susan Cover -- 623-1056

scover@centralmaine.com

Bookmark and share this story: digg del.icio.us Reddit


Reader comments

Sort by: Oldest first | Newest First

Leon Richard of Farmington, ME
Nov 29, 2007 1:12 PM
Carbohydrates are carbohydrates. Take one from a lump of sugar, and one from a potato, or one from a soda, your body doesn't know the difference.

Some foods are really rich in carbohydrates, some are not.

The issue isn't what we eat, but what we do with it. If we eat, and then sit and don't move, our body says, "Ooops, too much!" Insulin spikes, triglycerides spike, cholesterol levels increase, and our body stores the energy as fat.

If we move, our body uses the energy and doesn't store it as fat. Insulin levels remain more consistent, triglycerides remain steadier, and cholesterol levels remain low. Atherosclerosis doesn't form in that environment.

Adult onset diabetes, dyslipedemia, high blood pressure, and a host of other conditions "treated" now with expensive and lifelong medical approaches can be prevented and the use of the medical system generally can be reduced simply by exercising and watching the amounts of high carbohydrate foods one consumes.

The secret is the amount of food in, versus the amount of exercise or movement. Shift the equation one direction and weight loss happens. Shift the other way and weight gain occurs.

When the "tank is full" and the adipose tissues cannot really hold much more energy, because the person is obese, insulin resistance is the natural result. No matter how much insulin the body produces in response to a spike in blood sugar, the body cannot accept anymore. Blood sugar rises, and remains high for a prolonged period of time. Diabetes results from chronic elevation of blood sugar.

Move, eat less, and be healthier. Good health does not come from little brown plastic bottles full of expensive compensation for what we all are doing to ourselves.

report abuse
mikes of waterville, ME
Nov 28, 2007 2:30 PM
you go food nazi's. tell those kids what to eat and how to live. Dont stop there, there are many adults whos lives need to be "helped" too. but dont fear Hilary will fix this when she mandates health care for us all. report abuse
Josh of Farmington, ME
Nov 28, 2007 1:18 PM
Why is it that soda and other sugar-laden beverages are always to blame for the obesity epidemic?? Dora Mills, the director of Maine's Bureau of Health (who, coincidentally, is obese herself) shunned the beverage industry prior to Janet Blum's assertion that beverages are to blame. What about the starch infested foods the school cafeterias are so willingly dishing-out? I, for one, grew-up with bad food and beverage choices as well-- but you know what? I am not obese-- because I was active. That's right, physically active. It sickens me that the director of Maine's Bureau of Health can be overweight herself, yet report to the state that sugary beverages are to blame for Maine's obesity epidemic. Hypocrite? I think so. . . . Here's a solution: take-away computers from the schools and if you are not, in fact, fit yourself-- stop being a hypocrite.report abuse
Ben Stafford of Winslow, ME
Nov 28, 2007 11:28 AM
When has policing people's personal (legal) habits worked? The funny thing about food and sugar is most white and brown breads. Seriously, look at the ingredients of most breads. Corn Syrup (usually the high fructose kind) is a top ingredient. One school in central Maine has mandated the kids to bring snacks that the 1st three ingredients is not sugar. No bread for you! Sugar poison? Talk about overly dramatic. report abuse

Show all 11 comments

You must be a registered user of MaineToday.com to post a comment. Register or log in.