Morning Sentinel
Students hear different
take on global warming
By COLIN HICKEY
Staff Writer
Kennebec Journal & Morning Sentinel Wednesday, April 25, 2007

WATERVILLE -- Retired physics professor Howard Hayden does not dispute that global warming is happening.

But Hayden is an unabashed contrarian when it comes to assigning blame for the phenomenon.

Sports utility vehicle owners are innocent, he told his audience of about 90 people, most of them students, at Colby College on Tuesday afternoon.

The culprits, he said, are more likely astronomic and solar events.

"You think SUVs are the cause of glaciers shrinking?" he said to his audience. "I don't think so."

Hayden, though, certainly could be blamed for heating up debate on global warming causation, as well as debate between Democratic and Republican students at Colby.

Colby Republicans were the ones who invited Hayden to speak at the college, a presentation that took place in the Diamond Building.

Nathaniel Betz of the Colby Republicans said their objective was simply to provide a balanced account of an important issue.

"We are not trying to make this a partisan thing," he said.

Henry Beck of the Colby Democrats, however, had a different view.

"At times it was more an anti-Al Gore presentation," Beck said, "than a scientific presentation."

Hayden did poke fun at Gore in the course of trying to debunk the arguments of "An Inconvenient Truth," Gore's book and movie on global warming.

"Don't believe what you hear out of Hollywood and Washington, D.C.," Hayden said.

Hayden, a physics professor for 32 years at the University of Connecticut, is an editor of a monthly newsletter called "The Energy Advocate."

He also is the author of the book "The Solar Fraud: Why Solar Energy Won't Run the World."

In his presentation, Hayden blended humor with computer-generated images of various graphs and charts on global warming and carbon dioxide levels over the centuries and millennia.

He argued that climatic history proves that Gore has the relationship between carbon dioxide concentration and global warming backwards.

A higher concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, he said, does not cause the Earth to be warmer.

Instead, he said, a warmer Earth causes the higher carbon dioxide levels.

"The sun heats up the Earth," he said, "and the oceans warm up and atmospheric carbon dioxide rises."

Hayden said humans' contribution to global carbon dioxide levels is virtually negligible.

After the presentation, a Colby student asked Hayden to explain his belief that liberal politicians and the media promote the theory that humans are causing global warming.

Hayden said: "I don't pretend to understand people's motivation. I really don't."

But Hayden also said recent cap and trade policies earmarking big carbon dioxide emitters tend to benefit Third World countries and penalize highly industrialized nations.

Jacob Roundtree, executive director of Colby Republicans, said Gore's view on global warming also meshes well with the environmentalist agenda.

"Look at the people predisposed to that global warming view," he said. "They happen to be stewards of the environment."

Roundtree said he is not against protecting the environment but opposes promoting false information to achieve that goal.

Beck, in turn, rebutted the arguments of Hayden and Roundtree.

In a statement e-mailed after the event, Beck said Colby Democrats "believe that global warming is real and that governments must work toward solutions. Howard Hayden suggested that climate change science is a conspiracy by Al Gore and foreign governments. We reject that notion. This was political event about the issue of global warming."

Colin Hickey -- 861-9205

chickey@centralmaine.com


Reader comments

Sort by: Oldest First | Newest first

Leon Richard of Farmington, ME
Apr 25, 2007 6:29 AM
The guy sounds pretty smart to me. He's got my vote. I've said right along this is nothing more than an attempt to wrest resources and industry from the developed world and move it to the third world. The UN and the One World Government types have been trying to do this for years. They turn around and latch onto some "scientific" theory for something that is happening. There's no proof at all this is caused by man's activities or CO2.

Then the find 25,000 psychologists, english professors, political science professors, and a few "science" types, and suddenly they're going to save the world.

Do what you want to. The glaciers are going to melt until it cools off again. It will. See, what some people understand is that the earth, and nature, has NEVER been "in balance". It has always existed in a flux between the extremes. It visits the extreme in a cyclic manner over a varying time period. For anyone to believe we're to exist here for any amount of time and not see the extremes is as naive, simplistic, and foolish as gun control.

Wierd, most of the same faces you see at a global warming rally are the same ones you see marching around waving "Ban Guns" signs. Hmmm...report abuse
JThompson of Portland, ME
Apr 25, 2007 8:07 AM
Republicans certainly comprise the majority of the lower end of the intellectual spectrum.

Global warming and its causes stopped being a subject of debate a long time ago, yet these simpletons continue to stand up on the tree stump and scream in defense of anything that is wasteful and destructive. These cerebral troglodytes represent a barrier to the future health of everyone.

It's also shameful that Colby empowered these people in their focused diversion. What's next on the college republican speaking agenda up there, a holocaust denier?report abuse
CommonCents of Brunswick, ME
Apr 25, 2007 9:17 AM
Jthompson...care to justify your observation with Gore's transcripts from the two graduate schools he flunked out of--law & divinity?

When science gets in the way of raw political ambition, guess which suffers? report abuse
Laney of Augusta, ME
Apr 25, 2007 10:32 AM
Poor JThompson... so busy trying to dump stereotypes on Republicans that he doesn't see his own liberal ignorance. How typical. And also according to him, people who don't share his liberal viewpoint shouldn't even be allowed to speak. Democrats- the party embracing diversity (only when it agrees with them.)

What's realistic (regarding Global Warming) is something in the middle. Science has shown periods of the earth warming and cooling throughout time. "Global warming" isn't something that's suddenly appeared with SUVs and big corporations, no matter what the Democrats want you to believe. Global warming is a natural phenomenon- as are periods of Global cooling. And that's the sceintific truth (inconvenient as it is to Gore and his followers.)

That's not to say that we humans aren't making things worse- we should all be conscientious about what we do and try to be environmentally friendly, and also learn as much as we can about these topics.
report abuse

Show all 13 comments

You must be a registered user of MaineToday.com to post a comment. Register or log in.