Morning Sentinel
Bill targets liquor store-school distance
By SUSAN M. COVER
Staff Writer
Kennebec Journal & Morning Sentinel Tuesday, March 13, 2007

AUGUSTA -- Stores that sell liquor will need to get out their tape measures if a bill that further restricts their proximity to schools passes the Legislature.

A bill sponsored by Rep. W. Bruce MacDonald, D-Boothbay, would increase from 300 feet to 750 feet the distance from a school within which an agency liquor store can be located.

MacDonald, backed by Boothbay Harbor residents, Police Chief Robert Hasch and one high school student, said the local Rite-Aid in Boothbay Harbor, which sells hard liquor, is too close to the high school and YMCA.

By MacDonald's estimate, it's 640 feet from Boothbay Region High School.

He said alcohol is a problem among teenagers in Maine. It hurts brain development, MacDonald said, citing studies that show teens wouldn't abuse alcohol as much if it were harder to get.

"We know that access creates more problems, and that reducing access helps to minimize those bad outcomes," he told members of the Legal and Veterans Affairs Committee. MacDonald's bill would not grant exceptions for existing stores. If a store is closer than 750 feet to a school, the Maine State Police would have to hold a meeting in that town and allow the store to continue to sell hard liquor only if it is kept in a locked display case.

Opponents of the bill -- the Maine Liquor Agents Alliance, Hannaford Bros. Co., and others -- said it would be costly to store all liquor in locked cases and that it's a statewide solution for a Boothbay Harbor problem.

"During the past 20 years during which the current 300-foot limitation on agency store location has been in effect, there has been a complete absence of formal history of complaints about the sufficiency of the 300-foot limit," said Ralph B. Pears, a lobbyist who spoke on behalf of RSVP Beverages, Portland.

Rite-Aid spokeswoman Jody Cook said the Boothbay Harbor store has not had any violations for selling to minors and that its corporate policy is to ask for identification from anyone younger than 40.

When the store is crowded -- as it might be when school lets out -- the store has associates walk the aisles to monitor activity, she said.

Cook, who did not attend the public hearing, said the company doesn't have any comment on the bill.

"Of course, our intention is to only have that product available to adult consumers," she said.

Members of the legislative committee questioned MacDonald at length about his bill, prompting one to joke that he wins the prize for answering the most questions on any bill.

Rep. Bonnie Gould, R-South Berwick, said she needed more information about whether going from 300 to 750 feet would have a significant impact on whether teens abuse alcohol.

"It seems to me the access comes from my refrigerator or my unlocked liquor cabinet," Gould said.

Lt. Patrick Fleming of the Maine State Police offered testimony from the department that was neither for nor against the bill. While State Police want to keep teens away from alcohol, the bill would cost them money and time, he said. With more than 300 agency stores in the state, it would be time-consuming to remeasure each one, he said.

MacDonald said he would be willing to amend the bill so that the cost could be spread out over time.

Leah Hodder-Romano, 17, a junior at Boothbay Region High School, said students get a mixed message when they are warned about the dangers of drunken driving but can see banners advertising alcohol when they look out the window at school. Rep. Joan Nass, R-Acton, asked whether being close to the school might deter students from trying to get access because they would fear running into a teacher in the store.

"It might not be logical to go across the street where there are teachers, but it's not logical to get drunk either," Hodder-Romano replied.

Susan Cover -- 623-1056

scover@centralmaine.com


Reader comments

Sort by: Oldest First | Newest first

ronald masterman of wilton, ME
Mar 13, 2007 6:43 AM
if i can get a joint or some crack while in school what makes you think um going into a liquor store and rip off a bottle of crown, yall get a grip and stop wasting taxpayers money, besides i can trade a joint off to an adult for a pint, besides 99% off kids in school just drink beer.report abuse
RickinVa of Alexandria, VA
Mar 13, 2007 8:08 AM
The intention here is good, I suppose, however, what's next? Ban any store within 'x' number of feet from a school because they sell beer and cigarettes? Forbid gas stations from being near a school for fear of breathing in toxic fumes? Have kids walk a half mile to a bus stop because there is too much emission from the buses idling on school property? I think some people have too much time on their hands and we have too many people thinking up ridiculous restrictions. Maybe we should ban all type of stores completely and sell everything via the Internet and legislate that kids go to school online and can't step outside their homes until they reach the age of 18.report abuse
tunegal of Waterville, ME
Mar 13, 2007 8:46 AM
By far, this is the most ridiculous article I've read about to-date. I agree with other Reader Comments 100%. Responsibility of not selling to minors is the only issue here. A ban on child molesters and sex predators would be more appropriate, in keeping children safe from harmful things. Hypocrisy runs deep, on the subject of alcohol. For example: all the bars and restaurants that cater to the drunks who drive when they leave the establishment. They have no way of monitoring their alcohol level, and they don't walk home or call a taxi, and have no designated driver. They drink all night, and drive home. What makes anybody think that this is a safe practice for the public? Those drinkers should be the target of this issue. Leave the kids out of it, and don't sell to minors. A license to sell liquor is expensive. Merchants wont risk losing it by selling to a kid. Yet, adults are free to get drunk at every bar in town, and leave the joint to hop in their cars and drive down the street. Another confounding mystery of life..or death.report abuse
deb42 of norridgewock, ME
Mar 13, 2007 1:58 PM
The kids who drink are going to find alcohol one way or another. This ban while well intended isn't going to stop it. The best way to curb this problem is for the parents to get involved, talk to their kids about the dangers of this drug. About the dangers of drinking and driving. And to really mean it if you tell them that if they get in a situation where they and their friends may have been drinking. That you will come pick them up no questions asked. I'd rather get a call from them asking for a ride than one from the police. My children and their friends know that I'm against drinking period, but if there is a problem I'll come get them. report abuse

Show all 8 comments

You must be a registered user of MaineToday.com to post a comment. Register or log in.