Morning Sentinel
GOGAN SLAYING CASE
Woman seeks her old name
By DOUG HARLOW
Staff Writer
Kennebec Journal & Morning Sentinel Tuesday, March 13, 2007

SKOWHEGAN -- A former Hartland woman who spent more than five years in prison for killing her husband in 1999 has petitioned the county probate court to have her name changed.

Vella Gogan, 61, pleaded guilty to manslaughter in the shooting death and mutilation of Eugene Gogan in 1999 and was released from the Maine Correctional Center in Windham last summer.

She filed the necessary paperwork with the Somerset County Registry of Probate last month, according to documents.

Gogan's new name, if the petition is approved March 27 by Probate Judge John Alsop, will be Vella Ruth Pelletier.

"I want to go back to my maiden name," Gogan wrote in the application.

Contacted briefly by telephone Monday morning, Gogan declined to be interviewed.

Gogan originally was charged with murder in the Oct. 1, 1999, death of her husband, who was shot three times in the head as he slept in the couple's home on Route 43, Athens Road. The body of the 65-year-old man was cut into pieces and found six days later in the woods off Route 16 in Mayfield Township, north of Athens village and 25 miles from the couple's home.

Investigators recovered more than a dozen pieces of his body, including the torso and head.

Maine State Police detectives said the rest -- his hands, feet, parts of his legs and arms -- had been buried in shallow holes in the woods.

Vella Gogan said she had acted in self-defense against her husband of 37 years, who had been psychologically and physically abusive to her.

She said she feared her husband had planned to kill her. Two psychologists and two psychiatrists concluded she feared for her life and suffered from "battered-wife syndrome."

But the state prosecutor, Assistant Attorney General Andrew Benson, called Vella Gogan's actions a virtual execution and "the ultimate act of domestic violence."

Family members of Eugene Gogan agreed with Benson, saying the charge should have been murder. In an angry and emotional statement to the court and to Gogan, Susan Estes, a niece, said she felt betrayed by the court system, which she said had gagged family members and treated Eugene Gogan's killer as the victim.

"There's been no justice for his death," she said at the time.

Vella Gogan pleaded guilty to manslaughter in 2001 because she feared a jury might not agree that she acted in self-defense and convict her of murder, which carries a 25-year minimum sentence in Maine.

Gogan was sentenced to 15 years in prison, with all but six years suspended, and six years of probation.

A spokeswoman at the Department of Corrections said Gogan will be on probation until June 2012.

Cindy Dillon, clerk of the probate court in Skowhegan, said Gogan came in herself to file for the name change, a routine act by a widow or a woman who has been divorced.

"She does not have to come in for the hearing," Dillon said. "Adults changing their name don't have to come in unless a judge wants them to."

She said Alsop will review the petition March 27 and sign the order if it is approved and mail a certificate of name change to Gogan at her address on Middle Road, Skowhegan.

M. Michaela Murphy, a Waterville lawyer, along with lawyer Janet Mills of Skowhegan, represented Gogan in the manslaughter case. Murphy said Monday she has not had contact with her former client. Mills said she has spoken with Gogan and said she thought it was time to leave the case to history.

"I think the case is long over with and people should put it behind them," Mills said. "She has paid her dues."

Doug Harlow -- 861-9244

dharlow@centralmaine.com


Reader comments

Sort by: Oldest first | Newest First

previous page | next page1-10 of 14 comments:

Paul Durocher of Freeport, ME
Apr 17, 2009 10:43 PM
I'm not. She was a butcher. Get it? She had time to plan it out over her thirty year nightmare, so she cleaned up after herself. The idea of cutting someone up is harder to accept from someone who just watches bones from their couch while shoveling popcorn.

A soldier is a good example--they are taught to kill and to defend themselves and they're honored and told to return to civilian life where the rules are back to "normal." It doesn't make them dangerous. Just like Vella isn't dangerous since the only threat to her life is gone now.

ALFD of Canaan, ME, I'm glad you're not smart enough to be in "authority" over anything but a blog comment because you'd probably have that poor old woman in the electric chair after her miserable life of abuse.

By the way, she's my aunt, but we've never met, so I'm not standing up for her specifically--just battered women everywhere. I actually just happened to be reading, and I have a special place in my heart for redneck morons and their propensity for using extra punctuation!!!!
Rivaled only by the belief that others will somehow benefit from their opinion or even be interested.report abuse
welshie of augusta, ME
Feb 20, 2009 4:17 PM
The evidence presented in the Vella Gogan case has sufficiently proven that she experianced severe abuse, providing; the structure for a manslaughter conviction.However I take great issue with those who embellish the so called "truth".If there are those who cannot or will not accept the courts decision which was based on the vast amount of evidence presented then why would embellishment(same as lying to me)help anyone accept Vella Gogan's manslaughter convition?If Vella had shown up at my house as described by "eenie"of Farmington it would at least be memorable.My point is,that; It does not serve battered women to exagerate or lie(same thing)inorder to validate an abuse victims experiance. In fact it invalidates and undermines all the work many people have done and the laws designed to obliterate spousal abuse in our society.report abuse
eenie of farmington, ME
Dec 12, 2008 1:56 AM
I will catch hell for what I am about to say but it is the truth. I am a niece of Vella Pelletier. When I was a very young girl I remember that Vella would come to visit my mother, her sister.I vividly remember her terror and her tears.I also remember the awful black eyes and bruises on her body. I remember Vella crying hysterically to my mother terrified and afraid.Alot of times they would speak in french so that us kids would not understand.You who judge my aunt have no idea what you are talking about. Abuse is a terrible thing,the chain continues for many
generations. My mother herself married a very abusive man. My sisters and I went on to marry abusive men also.I stayed with a phony man for over 20 years and suffered terribly before I found the strength to get away.The breaking away and the aftermath and struggles of getting away, were harder than if I had just stayed in the situation.My mother stayed with my abusive stepfather decades as he abused us children.everyone in the community loved my husband and everyone in my childhood community loved my stepfather. After all he was a priest in our church! everyone also loved Gene. My real father and his wife tried to save us from the abuse but nobody believed. Even my mother stuck up for my stepfather.Us kids were told what to say also. We all lived the sick lie. No one believed that my husband was physically and sexually abusing my children either. Even after my x husband was finally arrested for child abuse, some still did not believe, they loved him. That is how manipulative and charming these men can be. My x husband was also a boy scout leader. I married my stepfather just as Vella married her sick father. The patterns repeat over and over.She knew nothing else.No one can ever possibly know or even speculate on what THEY would do unless they were in the same situation.unless they lived through years of physical and psychological abuse.Murder is wrong but how much could YOU endure before YOU SNAPPED.report abuse
Leon Richard of Farmington, ME
Mar 15, 2007 8:06 PM
It was a accident.... I'm sorry, I'm going to go hell...

In all seriousness... so long as you don't marry her and then abuse her, or even think about abusing her, or have her even think you'rethinking about abusing her, you should be all set.

It's the same old song and dance... "Evil men", "Evil men", Evil men." Maybe he did, maybe he didn't. Last time I looked you don't shoot people and cut them up in self-defense. Maybe shoot em... that I can see, even understand and nod my head to. Cuttin 'em up and scattering them around the countryside's a problem...

I'm sorry for everybody involved.report abuse
ALFD of Canaan, ME
Mar 13, 2007 5:10 PM
Is it just me or is there something really wrong with this picture?

Is anyone concerned with the fact that she not only shot him 3 times in the head (no doubt he was dead then)but after that she chopped him in over a dozen pieces!!!!!! Now she's mentally ok to live out in the community??? Are you people in authority serious? The fact that she's on probation/parole is NOT all that comforting, to be honest!report abuse
Leon Richard of Farmington, ME
Mar 13, 2007 5:09 PM
I fail to comprehend that the executor of Mr Gogan's will didn't sue her to force the name change. Likely didn't occur to them at the time. Would've been my first action if it had been me. Second would have been to freeze every asset held jointly or singly, and file a civil rights suit. I'd have taken everything she had, or would ever have, and given it to the kid, including his name. report abuse
TJ of Shenandoah Valley, VA
Mar 13, 2007 3:53 PM
Their child KNOWS the truth and lived it for many years. The child misses her Dad EVERYDAY!!! Despite what Vella GOGAN, her lawyers and the public says about him - Gene was a nice man and didn't deserve to die at the hands of his abuser. Men can be abused too! Most of them just chose to hide it because they're afraid to look weak.

Quote from dvmen.org: In 100 domestic violence situations approximately 40 cases involve violence by women against men. An estimated 400,000 women per year are abused or treated violently in the United States by their spouse or intimate partner. This means that roughly 300,000 to 400,000 men are treated violently by their wife or girl friend. report abuse
Colleen Kinney of york, SC
Mar 13, 2007 2:29 PM
There had to be a bored reporter here for today's paper.

Mrs. Gogan is now 61 years old and yet last summer was released from prison. Not much was said then. She is doing the best she can to turn her life around today and go on. Don' you reporters think she has gone through enough already.

Why is it such a big deal that she now wants her maiden name back? After all she is from a domestic violence situation. She deserves a clean slate now. Every one should leave her alone. Allow this woman to have a better life now.
As attourney Janet Mills stated " it is time to put this case to history". Let her be!

Mrs. Gogan to you, I say that you should keep trying to get past all this regardless of the publicity and the reporters. Turn your life toward the better and go forward. I wish you all the best in a new journey.report abuse
deb42 of norridgewock, ME
Mar 13, 2007 1:44 PM
I don't condone the act of violence this women committed whether in self defense or not; but I can understand why this women would want to change her name. But publishing the change in the paper kinda defeats her reasons doesn't it. report abuse
RickinVa of Alexandria, VA
Mar 13, 2007 1:40 PM
I guess the bottom line here is that nobody really knows what happened between these two people and one of them is dead. report abuse

previous page | next page

You must be a registered user of MaineToday.com to post a comment. Register or log in.