Morning Sentinel
Maine hospitals have tough task in attracting doctors
By BETTY ADAMS
Staff Writer
Kennebec Journal & Morning Sentinel Sunday, March 11, 2007

Today's Top Headlines
from the Kennebec Journal


All of today's: News | Sports
from the Kennebec Journal

AUGUSTA -- Luring a doctor to set up practice in central Maine is costly. Attracting a specialist can be even more expensive.

"There isn't any specialty position where someone couldn't go to another state and make more money," said George Hunter, vice president of administration at MidCoast Hospital in Brunswick. His responsibilities include recruiting and retaining doctors.

"Usually, people come to Maine because they get a reasonable salary and quality of life."

Getting them to stay here is another matter.

A "Physician Recruitment Agreement" made public after MaineGeneral Medical Center sued a doctor who left prematurely offers a rare glimpse of the efforts hospitals and others make to respond to community needs by recruiting physicians.

In its lawsuit, the hospital is demanding the physician, Dr. Eric L. Hensen, return a $375,000 advance.

Hensen, an osteopathic physician, was recruited to set up practice in MaineGeneral Medical Center's service area in Augusta and Waterville. The hospital offered a guaranteed income of $250,000 annually for the first two years, plus an additional $455,053 to set up a practice.

The hospital says Hensen, an ear, nose and throat specialist who closed his Augusta practice less than a year after opening it, left without making arrangements to repay the advance.

An affidavit by Dr. Stephen Sears, chief medical officer at MaineGeneral, said the hospital recruited Hensen and agreed to help him relocate to Maine from West Virginia.

Hensen has yet to file a response to the claim in court. Hensen is now practicing in New Mexico, according to his attorney, Michael Hodgins.

Those involved in the physician recruiting business say there's a lot of competition, too few doctors to go around, and the salaries are fairly standard, determined largely by the "Physician Compensation and Production Survey Report" published by the Medical Group Management Association.

The association conducts annual surveys of revenues and expenses for physician practices, analyzes it, and offers the data for sale. Currently, it offers "Physician Placement Starting Salary Survey Report: 2006 Report Based on 2005 Data."

Hospitals across Maine report a total of 204 physician vacancies, with the greatest need seen in primary care providers, followed closely by specialists. Match that with the fact that most other states are recruiting as well and with predictions of continuing shortages, particularly in certain disciplines.

Maine's openings, by practice specialty, are listed by the Maine Recruitment Center, a nonprofit arm of the Maine Hospital Association.

Jane Ham, recruitment center director, says the center forwards names of candidates to hospitals and private practices and then the hospitals or other employers conduct interviews and deal with contract negotiations.

"Using recruitment agreements is commonplace," Hunter said. "It's necessary because it's very difficult to recruit, particularly subspecialities."

Generally, doctors are recruited to meet specific needs in a community.

Salaries tend to be determined by region, and the survey by Medical Group Management Association shows that physicians generating a particular amount of revenue earn a certain salary.

"The report is the gold standard for data on physician compensation and production," according to the association's Web site.

Hunter agrees.

"Most people make market-based offers and most doctors are aware of what the market will bear," Hunter said.

In this field, as in many others, location matters.

"The more desirable the location, the easier it is," Hunter said. "On the coast, we're half an hour away from everything -- Augusta, Lewiston, Portland. Having a good location helps."

He said Maine competes on a national scale for ear, nose and throat specialists, urologists and orthopedists.

He said since salaries tend to be comparable -- because everyone is looking at the same survey -- a decision to relocate is based on other factors:

"Is this the place I want to live? Will I have colleagues to work with? If I'm the only ENT in town, I don't want to be covering every night and weekend."

Hunter said recruiting practices for physicians are limited by federal guidelines. The Stark Physician Referral law and Anti-kickback Statute prevent physicians from referring patients to entities in which the doctors have a financial interest.

Gordon Smith, of the Maine Medical Association, says low reimbursement rates for treating Medicare patients also contribute to Maine's physician shortage.

Betty Adams -- 621-5631

badams@centralmaine.com


Reader comments

Sort by: Oldest first | Newest First

reader of Portland-Boston, ME
Mar 11, 2007 7:18 PM
MDs drive a Lexus or Benzs and like to live in upper crust communities. It is part of their reward for going to college and medical school for 8 years and having a strendous job. What person who drives an expensive vehicle wants to drive one on the roads of Central Maine?? And what central Maine community is an MD going to be happy living in?

If you want professional people like MDs and dentists to move to central maine, central Maine needs to change and offer amn upper crust community or two that an MD is going to want to call home.report abuse
omar of Clinton, ME
Mar 11, 2007 4:27 PM
Colleen has it right - if you have the money the doctor is always in.

Perhaps part of the problem is the QUALITY of the doctors who work here - no one ever comes to Maine for medical care. The best and brightest don't want to treat poor old people who are only getting poorer and older. Unless we paid them A LOT. You can't buy love, but you can buy medical care.

It's called National Health Insurance.report abuse
Leon Richard of Farmington, ME
Mar 11, 2007 8:45 AM
Look to Augusta's nanny-state insurance and medical care laws for the reason why you can't find a doctor here in Maine. Also look to them for the explanation why people without insurance have a more difficult time to get care here in Maine.

We have no practical method by which a private individual can purchase medical coverage here. There are few companies now that even do business in Maine, and fewer Mainers can afford to purchase insurance.

With regard to doctors taking care of people regardless of their ability to pay. I decided not to go to medical school a few years ago. If I were independently wealthy, I'd probably do it today. However, I want to remain here in Maine. It's where I live, and my home. I was born here, and I'll die and be buried here. I can't afford it, that's the end.

Doctors spend a minimum of 11 years in school to become trained in their chosen specialty so they might begin their own practice. This is usually spent with little to no income, and certainly no "measurable income". In other words, whatever they "earn" during that time is immediately gobbled up by their expenses. To top this off, usually they graduate from medical school with a debt load of over 100,000 dollars.

So, let me make sure I understand. After I spend 11 years, hundreds of thousands of dollars, endless hours of study, endure thousandss of hours of stressful internships and residency. Then I graduate from medical school, become board certified at considerable expense, open a practice at my own cost, hire staff and be responsible for their continued employment, and provide the best care I can to the greatest number of people. But, I can't refuse to treat anybody regardless of their ability to pay?

How long do you figure the bank will allow me to do that? My estimation is about three months. Then my employees are out of work, and nobody gets care.

The "Oath" requires justice and fairness. So long as it is not a danger to my continuing to care for other patients.report abuse
Colleen Kinney of york, SC
Mar 11, 2007 7:10 AM
Well, I will tell you what. I really can't say I have a whle lot of faith in the medical care.
As long as you have money or some kind of insurance then a doctor is more than happy to see you at any time at all.
However, if you do not have either, then on the first phone call the front desk stops the patient shotr as soon as they hear that information. At that point all they want to do is get you OFF their phone, nevermind make an appointment. And you can forget seeing the doctor. I thought that when they graduated they took an oath to care for anyone regarless of income, but now a days definately not the case at all.report abuse

You must be a registered user of MaineToday.com to post a comment. Register or log in.