Morning Sentinel
Blogger gets OK to attend trial of Scooter Libby
BY NOEL K. GALLAGHER
MaineToday Media, Inc.
Kennebec Journal & Morning Sentinel Saturday, January 13, 2007

Maine political blogger Lance Dutson will cover next week's Scooter Libby trial for perjury and obstruction of justice, joining the first group of bloggers to receive credentials to a federal court trial.

"I am excited about it," said Dutson, who runs a Web site design company out of his Searsmont home and blogs at www.mainewebreport.com. "It's an interesting and positive development and shows a pretty progressive attitude toward the changing media landscape."

Media Blogger Association, a 1,000-member group that got two reserved seats, will rotate Dutson and other members through the seats for the 6- to 8-week trial that begins Tuesday. Several individual bloggers have also been credentialed, a court official said.

"I have been working with the folks at the federal judiciary for over a year to create this opportunity," association President Bob Knox wrote in a post this week on www.mediabloggers.org. "Behind this may be many additional opportunities with the federal and state supreme courts so getting this one right opens up the door to many other cool things. Other institutions will surely be looking at this as well."

The bloggers will be limited to seats in a media overflow room, which Knox said he requested, since they couldn't be guaranteed seats in the courtroom itself and because the media center would have wireless Internet access, allowing them to file updates throughout the day. The trial is expected to draw unprecedented attention at the U.S. District Court in the District of Columbia, which set up the media center for the first time to meet media request demands, said Sheldon Snook, administrative assistant to Chief Judge Thomas Hogan.

Libby, former chief of staff for Vice President Dick Cheney, is charged with perjury and obstruction of justice in connection with the leak of the name of then-active CIA operative Valerie Plame. Cheney is expected to testify.

"We view this as a trial. By giving credentials to five or six different bloggers, it will give us a good sense of how this works," Snook said. "The chief judge and our (information technology) committee have always appreciated the advantages that technology can bring."

The decision to give bloggers credentials sets no precedent, Snook said, since federal judges decide media rules on a case-by-case basis.

But it adds to the ongoing debate about the fuzzy line between traditional media and bloggers, particularly "citizen journalist" bloggers who do actual reporting work, as opposed to the vast majority of blogs that are either commentary or "diary" style musings. According to Technorati, a blog-tracking company in San Francisco, there are already at least 63.2 million blogs online, with more than 175,000 new blogs added every day.

"The critical thing is the work that people are doing, whether they're called bloggers or journalists" said Bill Mitchell, editor of Poynter Online, the online arm of The Poynter Institute, a continuing education program for journalists. "If they are gathering news, then I don't think there's any particular reason to deny them access. If it's a matter of space, then people have to make that decision. But I certainly wouldn't exclude bloggers for their lack of affiliation with a media company."

Dutson said he hasn't ever been excluded from an event or denied access because he was a blogger, but he's emboldened by the court's decision.

"After the trial, I'll be pushing to test my access to stuff in the state of Maine and having had this experience is going to make it easier to make the arguments that I be allowed access," he said. "It's been a long road to gain access to people and get people to return calls and to have them look at the merit of the information and not the medium."


Reader comments

Sort by: Oldest first | Newest First

1-5 of 5 comments:

Linda of Bangor, ME
Mar 28, 2008 1:11 PM
Finally - the recording of that silly Augusta meeting about pay-per-click.

Dutson panicked and ran.

http://dutsonlies.wordpress.com/2008/03/28/lance-dutson-flees-augusta-meeting/report abuse
Linda Hutchins of Bangor, ME
Oct 17, 2007 1:44 PM
http://lindahutchins.wordpress.com/

Fall cleaning update...thanks. ;-)
report abuse
Linda Hutchins of Bangor, ME
Mar 13, 2007 7:16 PM
There is a very intersting update to this story....

http://bangorreports.blogspot.com/

It seems that now even Maine PBN (Specifically, the humble farmer) has taken up with this troll, without lifting a finger to check him out.

Thanks for your time.


Lindareport abuse
Linda Hutchins of Bangor, ME
Feb 23, 2007 5:00 PM
There is an update to this story...Cox admits that he did read Dutson's blog up until May of 2006, but since then he as only "Skimmed" it I have some emails from him admitting this.

Whole story here:

HTTP://truthaboutlewis.blogspot.com

Thank you--report abuse
Seeker of Bangor, ME
Jan 20, 2007 12:21 PM
I have been made aware that Robert Cox of the Media Bloggers Association is planning to arrange a seat at the Libby trial for one of his bloggers - Lance Dutson of

HTTP://mainewebreport.com

I have been following Mr Dutson's blog for some time, and have come to learn that most of his accusations are brazenly untrue .... untruths about which he has repeatedly been made aware. He has even admitted to knowing that some are inaccurate, but these admissions eventually disappear... and off he goes again, on another rant.

Lance Dutson came out of the gate swinging, and has consistently and pugilistically ignored any invitation to reasonable discourse.

Robert Cox informs me that he has never even read Dutson's blog. I find this, if true, to be an act of extreme negligience.

If you do read Dutson's blog, you will see that the headlines are never corroborated by fact, but rather, link only to more of his own accusations, or even to documents which actually CONTRADICT these accusations.

Apparently, people only read the headlines, and nothing else. And they mindlessly believe them.

He appears to get the most gratification out of making searingly vicious personal attacks on total strangers whom he somehow perceives as enemies. And this list grows longer every day.

If anyone disagrees with him in a comment, he turns his hatred on that commenter, with vicious lies about him.

Or he deletes the comment entirely.

He behaves like a web troll, and nothing else but. I find it unfathomable that anyone would assign a seat at the Libby trial, and its resultant journalistic credibility, to someone without ever having checked his credentials.

Web trolls should be eliminated - not elevated.



report abuse

You must be a registered user of MaineToday.com to post a comment. Register or log in.